MForum.ru
25.05.2006,
Telenor once again finds it necessary to correct information distributed by Altimo in its press release dated 22 May 2006. Telenor has also written a letter to Altimo requesting clarification on some key issues raised in the press. As we sincerely believe that talks on VimpelCom’s purchase of Kyivstar, in which Telenor holds a controlling stake, will continue, we ask you to please note the points below for future reference in relation to this subject:
• Altimo claims that Telenor is unreasonable in demanding FAS approval to buy up to 100% of VimpelCom shares
o In order for a separation mechanism to be effective, both parties involved must apply for and receive in advance approval from the Russian Federal Antimonopoly Service (FAS) to buy up to 100% of VimpelCom shares. This is due to the combined requirements of the Russian Federation Joint Stock Company Law and the Antimonopoly Law.
o Telenor has never asked for an “unlimited” FAS approval – this would be inconsistent with the RF Antimonopoly Law.
o Telenor has spoken with both VimpelCom and Altimo about the need for the three parties to approach the FAS in an organized way and demonstrate that all three are in agreement on the proposed Kyivstar transaction. Telenor believes that the FAS and the Russian government expect Altimo and VimpelCom to act in a coordinated way with Telenor on this issue.
o There is no current legal basis upon which the FAS can refuse to grant approval to Telenor’s application to acquire up to 100% of VimpelCom shares.
• Altimo claims that Telenor is undermining talks by refusing to sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA).
o If appropriate at a future stage of negotiations, Telenor will sign an NDA. Telenor sees no need for such an agreement under the current circumstances.
o From the start, the circumstances of the proposed Kyivstar transaction have been somewhat unusual: VimpelCom's initial confidential proposal concerning the transaction was leaked to the press before Telenor even had an opportunity to respond to it. As a result, since that time, all discussions between the parties have been subject to media scrutiny.
o Telenor’s policy is to be as transparent and open about the progress of negotiations as possible in order to prevent any misinformation or misrepresentations by any party and to keep other shareholders in VimpelCom informed.
o Telenor is unwilling to enter into an NDA in a situation in which it is the only party honoring the NDA and the other party or parties are selectively leaking information to the media in order to improve their negotiating positions or score PR victories. Telenor's experience with Alfa to date has been that Alfa is willing to violate the terms of agreements to which it is a party when it suits Alfa's business purposes.
o Altimo asked for an NDA from Telenor prior to yesterday's (22 May 2006) meeting with the full knowledge that they had planned a press conference and press release BEFORE the meeting.
• Altimo refuses to accept Telenor’s proposal that no conditions be attached to or third parties be involved in the separation mechanism.
o Similar separation mechanisms have been used in other deals, and Alfa is no stranger to such arrangements
o Any conditions or involvement of third parties would give rise to an increased likelihood of lawsuits and other claims – meaning Alfa could continue to violate agreements and be confident that Telenor would not be able to trigger the separation mechanism without facing years of litigation.
o It is not Telenor’s position that the separation mechanism should be triggered simply to end our partnership with Alfa. If Alfa were to change its behavior, it is possible the parties could return to the constructive partnership that we have had in the past. But there must be structure in place to provide for a clean separation in the event this does not occur.
• Altimo claims that Telenor is pursuing “unending” lawsuits against VimpelCom and its management
o The party pursuing “unending” lawsuits has been Alfa, both in Russia and recently in Ukraine where seven different lawsuits have been initiated by various Alfa affiliates
o Telenor has launched three lawsuits against VimpelCom in connection with the URS transaction, which we believe was overpriced and lacked business merit, in addition to being authorized by a shareholder meeting convened and held in violation of Russian law and VimpelCom's charter
o We believe that unwinding the URS transaction is in the best interests of VimpelCom and its shareholders
o These lawsuits would not be necessary if Alfa and VimpelCom’s management had not violated the law and VimpelCom’s charter.
• Altimo claims that VimpelCom’s offer to buy Kyivstar will soon expire
o As Altimo is aware, large transactions of this nature are complex and require a number of steps to complete, as indicated in the tentative timetable in Telenor’s letter to Altimo dated 10 May
o No transaction can realistically be completed in “the coming days.”
o Telenor, Altimo and VimpelCom have discussed transaction roadmaps that contemplate the process taking some months
• Altimo’s spokesman says talks with Telenor have ended
o Telenor is puzzled by the statements of Altimo’s spokesman, Mr. Babaev, which are contrary to what Altimo's representatives expressed in their 22 May videoconference with Telenor. Telenor has therefore written a letter to Altimo’s management requesting clarification on this and other issues.
©
Публикации по теме:
18.10. [English] Conflicts: Telenor requests Kievstar convene two extraordinary general shareholders meetings / MForum.ru
10.10. [English] Conflicts: Telenor statement on Alfa 13-D filing regarding VimpelCom share ownership / MForum.ru
05.09. [English] Conflicts: Moscow Court Requests VimpelCom to Disclose Additional Information Regarding URS Acquisition / MForum.ru
03.08. [English] Conflicts: Telenor’s comments regarding Altimo’s claims on the latest developments in Ukrainian courts / MForum.ru
01.08. [English] Conflicts: Court Forces VimpelCom to Disclose URS Documents / MForum.ru
04.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Honor Play 60 и Play 60m представлены официально / MForum.ru
04.04. [Новинки] Слухи: Раскрыт дизайн Motorola Razr 60 и Razr 60 Ultra / MForum.ru
03.04. [Новинки] Слухи: Samsung работает над более доступным складным смартфоном / MForum.ru
03.04. [Новинки] Слухи: Honor работает над смартфоном с АКБ емкостью 8000 мАч / MForum.ru
02.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Motorola Edge 60 Fusion представлен с изогнутым дисплеем и рейтингом IP69 / MForum.ru
02.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Lava Bold 5G за 11 рупий представлен официально / MForum.ru
01.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Vivo V50e получил мощную фоточасть и выдержал 42 000 падений / MForum.ru
01.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Представлены Vivo Y300 Pro+ и Y300t с емкими АКБ / MForum.ru
01.04. [Новинки] Анонсы: Poco F7 Pro на базе Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 представлен официально / MForum.ru
31.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Poco F7 Ultra – первый смартфон бренда на флагманском чипсете / MForum.ru
28.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Представлен Infinix Note 50x с прочным корпусом и большой батареей / MForum.ru
27.03. [Новинки] Слухи: iQOO Z10 будет поддерживать быструю зарядку 90 Вт / MForum.ru
26.03. [Новинки] Слухи: Oppo Pad 4 Pro появился на тизерах / MForum.ru
26.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Lava Shark дебютирует с дисплеем 120 Гц и аккумулятором 5000 мАч / MForum.ru
25.03. [Новинки] Слухи: OnePlus 13T получит «невероятную» ёмкость АКБ / MForum.ru
24.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Представлены Oppo F29 и F29 Pro с прочными корпусами и емкими батареями / MForum.ru
24.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Samsung Galaxy A26 5G представлен официально / MForum.ru
21.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Google представила Pixel 9a с чипсетом Tensor G4 / MForum.ru
21.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Vivo Y19e – смартфон с экраном 90 Гц и емким АКБ за 8000 рупий / MForum.ru
21.03. [Новинки] Анонсы: Vivo V50 Lite 5G с Dimensity 6300, АКБ 6500 мАч и зарядкой 90 Вт представлен официально / MForum.ru